Monday, April 29, 2019

2.15 In-Class Write - Argo

Argo Write - In Class

1. Argo does an amazing job setting the first scene up in the movie with background information before it dives straight into the characters and events that take place in the movie. At the beginning there is a narrator that talks about the history of Iran and how it was a Persian Empire that was ruled by Kings for 2500 years known as Shahs. The movie talks about the election of Mohammad Mosaddegh who was a secular democrat that became Prime Minister. Mohammad Mosaddegh had the support of his people because he was able to return Iran's oil to his people. The movie also mentions that in 1953 the U.S. and Great Britain arrange a coup to overthrow and install a new Shah to Iran. The U.S. choose to install Reza Pahlavi, and he did a terrible job at pleasing his population. It was said that people starved, his wife bathed in milk, wanted to westernize Iran, and had a ruthless internal police known as the SAVAK all of which enraged his people. In 1979 the Shah was overthrown and Iran soon became entangled in score settling, death squads, and chaos which led to the former Shah being taken in by the U.S. The people of Iran then took the U.S. Embassy in an act of rage and demanded the Shah to be returned, tried, and hanged.
     Many of the events that took place in the movie were historically accurate. Six U.S. Embassy hostages did manage to escape and hide out in the Canadian Ambassadors property. The U.S. did send in a CIA Agent in to extract the stranded hostages with the plan being to pretend that they were filming a movie, 'Argo', in Iran. The airport scenes were dramatized but the hostages did really go through customs and fly their way out of Iranian airspace even with many pressing threats such as immigration officials, revolutionary guards, and flight details and paperwork. Studio Six Productions was a fake Hollywood company that was fully funded by the CIA in order to better convince the Iranian immigration control that the movie was actually happening and it helped to fully credidate their cover story as a production crew. Thankfully, the 6 American hostages and the 2 CIA Agents were able to safely make their trip back to America and were greeted with open arms after their many days spent in Iran.

2. One of the most important historical facts that was left out of the movie was that the Canadian government actually had much more to do with the operation than the film portrays. The movie also does not show that there was a second CIA Agent, Lee Schatz, who helped Tony Mendez in the extraction of the American hostages. The movie does not go into depth with the time that the Americans spent in hiding but they had been with the ambassador for about 80 days before this extraction took place. Mendez actually left early the morning of the escape and scouted out the airport to ensure that everything was going to plan and there would not be any surprises waiting for them as they walked by.
     The airport scene was one of the most dramatized portions of the movie. Although the Americans did have to travel through customs and board the plane, there were many discrepancies between what actually took place. The Americans spent many long hours in the crowded, clogged, and chaotic airport wondering when they would finally be home. The hostages flight was actually delayed an hour so they all had to wait in the departure lounge for an extra hour while revolutionary guards were making their rounds. In an interview after the escape Agent Mendez recalls that he knew that the final stop (customs) would be the weak spot if any in the escape. He knew that the patrol officers would have to correctly identify and match the current health card with the one you receive when entering Iran. If the match would have failed than the whole mission would have been a bust and the escape would have never happened. When Mendez handed the guards his card they went to a back room and he was not sure what they were doing but it turns out that the guards had actually just taken a tea break and when they came back they stamped the Americas through to the terminal. Once out of the Iranian airspace it was not only just the Americans but the whole plane was cheering now that they could escape from the violent and lawless streets of Iran.

3. I think if the filmmaker had another 20 minutes that he could have added a scene with the actual hostages stuck in the Embassy to show what could have been for the six that escaped. This would historically show some of the terrible circumstances that were just narrowly avoided and it would help to add suspense and pull on the heart strings of the audience knowing that there are still many hostages still stuck in Iran. This would also add a chance for another movie because it is almost as if the work is not done until everybody is free from Iran and back in the U.S. Overall I think that 'Argo' hit many of the main points of the operation and extraction of the 6 hostages, the only thing I would add would be a scene in the embassy that shows some of the hard times and rough road that some of the hostages had to face while being held for 444 days.

2.14 Annotated Sources - Argo

Annotated Sources:

Argo - Iranian Hostage Crisis Movie.

US History Textbook "Hostage Crisis" pg.190-191 - Iranian Hostage Crisis overview, and US security agreements with other countries.

Argo Film Locations - This source talked about the real life film locations used in Argo to make the movie look like it was filmed in Iran.

CIA - Document on 6 CIA Hostages Held captive.

CIA Agent Recalls Escape - Former CIA Agent gives details on how the operation unfolded and some of the challenges/obstacles that arose.

2.13 Menu - Argo

Iranian Hostage Crisis Menu -

Water is a necessity and resembles life for the hostages that survived being captured for 444  days.

Macallan would be used to help calm the nerves of the worrisome hostages while they were behind enemy lines.

Leek soup is easily prepared so it would be used as the appetizer and would help show how little initiative was taken by the captors to ensure enough was being done in order to take of the hostages.

The hamburger is an American favorite and would be served at the dinner party because the hostages were away from some of their favorite American foods for such a long time.
Sangak bread is a typical Iranian side for dishes and would represent the bare minimum of food given to the Americans while they were Held hostage in Iran.

The chocolate cake would be used as dessert and would help to remind the hostages of the food that they were taken away from for 444 days while being held hostage.

2.12 Exhibit - Argo

Iranian Hostage Crisis Exhibit -

Actual business cards used by fake film crew in rescue of Hostages.


Image of Cover to book about covert operation to extract 6 American Hostages.

Image of actual script of "Argo" used as evidence of film project to help escape the hostages in hiding.
Image from a letter written by Jimmy Carter regarding the release of the hostages.

Image of crowd awaiting the arrival of the Iranian Hostages.

Telegram that confirms the known details of the Iranian Hostage Crisis.

Image of Hostage being held while in Iran.
Image of US Embassy being stormed.

2.11 Invitation - Argo

Guests:
Ambassador Taylor - The Canadian Ambassador at the time of Iranian Hostage Crisis, would make a good guest because of his actual first hand experience of the Hostage Crisis and some of the information that he could provide while at dinner.
Ben Affleck - Plays Tony Mendez who was an actual CIA Agent, would be a good guest because he could provide his expertise in the film industry and provide information on the film industry for the actual participants in the Hostage Crisis.
John Goodman - Plays make up artist, John Chambers, would be a good guest to have because of his humor and easily sociable attitude.
Tony Mendez - Actual CIA Agent, would be a good guest because he could specialize in giving some of the details in planning and preparation for an operation like this to take place.
Robert Anders - Actual Hostage Crisis Survivor, would be a good guest because he was the oldest of the hostage group and seemed to take charge and make the calls on what should be done next.
Joseph Stafford - Actual Hostage Crisis Survivor, would be able to provide a detailed account of what all took place while the Hostage Crisis was unfolding.
Kathleen Stafford - Actual Hostage Crisis Survivor, would make a good guest because she would be able to speak on some of the emotions and actions that took place to flee the embassy and reside in enemy territory for so long.
Mathew Wald - Writer for New York Times, would make a good guest because of his close work with the Argo cast and the actual survivors of the Iranian Hostage Crisis so would be able to spark conversation on both sides.

Monday, April 15, 2019

2.10 Thinking Like a Historian

Sign in a Chicago Park in 1917 that is deterring German Americans from entering.

The conditions for German Americans became unbearable in World War 1 and they were being targeted constantly by the American society. German Americans were the receivers of much hostility from Americans that were fearful of a German revolt on their own home soil.

Monday, April 8, 2019

2.9 Criminal justice Essay

Complications Prisoners Face Trying to Re-Enter Society
     Incarcerated people face obstacles while trying to reenter into society after being in prison or jail. I will be showing my research and data that I gathered about the three most prominent challenges that ex-convicts face after prison. African American ex-convicts face a particularly harsh road after incarceration and are set up to fail in society with a criminal record. African American convicts face a stigma and discrimination like no other when it comes to reentry into society after serving a sentence.
     African American men in particular face a challenging and harsh environment that actively deters them from being productive in society. 3 years after release, 67.8% are rearrested and 5 years after release that number jumps to 76.6%. It is very difficult to navigate the legal and social barriers that are presented to them after incarceration. Employment is another issue that actively deters ex-convicts from becoming productive members in society. A past criminal conviction reduced the likelihood of a job offer by 50%, this leads to a valuable work force that is being overlooked for the crimes they committed in the past. African American offenders are 2/3 less likely to receive job offers from companies, and African American non-offenders are 1/2 as likely to see the same job offers. No national law has been set in stone to help ex-convicts with employment, but some states have begun adopting a "ban the box" or "fair chance laws" to improve employment among ex-convicts. Sadly, 1/3 of the adult working age population has a criminal record, and more than 70 million have been indexed by the FBI.
     With all of the men and women with a criminal record in the United States, it is becoming harder to meet housing requirements. 4/5 tenants are expected to run a background check on who they are renting out to and for many of the people with criminal records this prevents them from choosing this particular path for housing. The other problem with housing is that in urban areas the public housing is already at a shortage which makes it twice as hard for people with criminal records to find affordable and suitable housing conditions for where they are in their life. Homelessness is also a major problem with ex-convicts and unemployment plays a large role in this part of the process. With no one to turn to, friends and family are an ex-convicts only option to reintegrate to society. Being away to prison for such a long time can take a toll on those tight knit relationships which in turn ends many of the past relationships that they might have had. The situations are amplified when juveniles go off to prison or jail for long periods of time.
     Juvenile face unique challenges compared to any other population after incarceration. Juveniles typically have limited experience of the "outside world" which makes it difficult to reintegrate into a society that they were never really a part of in the past. Juveniles in these criminal justice systems have never done simple and even mundane everyday tasks such as driving a car, owning a bank account, successfully searching for housing, or holding a steady job. Juveniles need support reentering into society with the mental and emotional roller coaster that they will face outside of incarceration. They will need to be guided on their journey for housing, employment, education, and even basic friendships with people around them.
    African American convicts face a stigma and discrimination like no other when it comes to reentry into society after serving a sentence. The criminal justice system does not do a very good job of providing support for formerly incarcerated people trying to integrate back into society, this is probably why the national recidivism rate is 43.3%. This leads to the ongoing cycle for most prisoners of re-incarceration and feeding themselves back into the system. Someone needs to push for change to overcome these massive barriers that the system seems to push onto formerly incarcerated people. In order to overcome these barriers the society that these people are coming back to needs to provide support and encouragement for these men and women that are trying to control their own lives again.


Sources:
www.correctionalofficer.org - Criminal Justice Overview
eji.org - Equal Justice Initiative Incarceration Reentry to Society
www.brennacenter.org - Criminal Records Effect in Society
socialwork.simmons.edu - Challenges of Prisoner Reentry Into Society
scholar.utc.edu - Challenges of Reentering Society for Incarcerated African American Men
prospect.org - After Incarceration, What's Next?